Our Menu
MP - Market Price
Hors d Ouevres - Savory
Feeds 20 people 1 serving
Stuffed Mushrooms
$40.00
Vegetable Tray
$40.00
Wisconsin Sausage & Cheese Platter
$40.00
Meatballs
$40.00
Bourbon and Brown Sugar Bites
$40.00
Bruschetta
$40.00
Spinach Rolls
$40.00
Veg. option
Caprese
$40.00
Pinwheels
$40.00
Veggie or Meat
Taco Dip
$40.00
Won Tons
$40.00
Chicken Salad Won Tons
$40.00
Mini Croissant Sandwiches
$60.00
Rib Tips
$60.00
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
$60.00
Chicken Drummies and Wingettes
MP
Hors d Ouevres - Sweet
Banana Puddin
Cups $3.00 | 1/2 Pan (10 people) $25.00 | Full Pan (20 people) $50.00
Peach Cobbler
Cups $3.00 | 1/2 Pan (10 people) $25.00 | Full Pan (20 people) $50.00
Chicken & Waffle Boats
$20.00/12 Pieces
Sweet Potato Tarts
Small Tray $20.00 | Large Tray $40.00
Fruit Tray
Small Tray $20.00 | Large Tray $40.00
Fruit Torte
Small Tray $20.00 | Large Tray $40.00
Charcuterie
We put heart into our Charcuterie Boards (and cups!) - made just for you and whatever party you’ve got going on. Whether it’s a fancy holiday bash or just a laid-back hangout, pick what you love or let Carmell surprise you • Small (feeds 10) $65.00 | Medium (feeds 20) $100.00 | Large (2 boards, feeds 50) $150.00
Cured Meats
Choice of Cheeses
Meat and Cheese Rolls
Fruits
Nuts
Sweets
Party Themes
Need some inspiration for your party? Check out our themed menus below!
All American BBQ
$25.00/pp
Chicken, ribs, hot dogs, BBQ, baked beans, coleslaw or potato salad, relish tray, white bread.
Mexican Fiesta
$25.00/pp
Tacos, enchiladas, beans, Spanish. rice, tamales, chips & salsa (entrees in beef, chicken, pork, or combination, hot tortillas.
Classic
$25.00/pp
Ham, turkey & stuffing, macaroni, string bean casserole, choice of vegetable, dinner rolls.
Seafood Feast
$35.00/pp
Seafood fettuccine, cod (baked or battered), shrimp cocktail, snow crab, garlic mashed potatoes, vegetable medley, hush puppies.
Chicken / Turkey Entrees
Fried Chicken
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00
House Seasoned Baked Chicken
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00
BBQ Chicken
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00
Marinated Garlic & Herb Chicken
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00
Bourbon Brown Sugar Chicken
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00 • Baked or Grilled
Roasted / Smothered Turkey
1/2 Pan (16-18 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $110.00 • Baked or Grilled
Whole Turkey
MP
Beef
Brisket
1/2 Pan (14-16 pieces) $85.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $175.00
Beef Roast
1/2 Pan (14-16 pieces) $60.00 | Full Pan (40-50 pieces) $100.00
Vegetarian
Lasagna
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Ravioli
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Spaghetti
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Mac n’ Cheese
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Autumn Bake
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00 • Yams, golden potatoes, vegetables.
Cabbage and Kale
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Roasted Vegetables with Pasta
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00
Stuffed Peppers
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $75.00 • With Veg & Rice.
Pork
Pulled Pork
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $90.00
Smothered Pork Chops
1/2 Pan (10 chops) $50.00 | Full Pan (30 chops) $120.00
Spare Ribs
1/2 Pan (20 bones) $65.00 | Full Pan (50 bones) $130.00
Baby Back Ribs
1/2 Pan (20 bones) $65.00 | Full Pan (50 bones) $130.00
Rib Tips
Half Pan $65.00 | Full Pan $130.00
Fish
Perch
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Tilapia
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Catfish Nuggets
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Cod
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • Baked or Fried
Seafood Alfredo
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • Baked or Fried
Seafood Lasagna
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • Baked or Fried
Seafood Mac n’Cheese
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • Baked or Fried
Salmon
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • Baked or Fried
Catfish
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $75.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $150.00 • Baked or Fried
Vegan
Eggplant Lasagna
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Cabbage Rolls
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Roasted Vegetables with Pasta
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Stuffed Peppers
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00 • With veg & rice
Cauliflower Bourbon & Brown Sugar
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $50.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $100.00
Cornbread Muffins
$15.00
12 Muffins
Sides
Collard Greens
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $80.00 • Smoked Meat
Mac n' Cheese
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $40.00 | Full Pan (20 servings) $80.00
Mashed Potatoes / Gravy
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Black - Eyed Peas
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Coleslaw
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Pasta Salad
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Potato Salad
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Cabbage and Kale
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Baked Beans
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Rice Pilaf
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Dressing
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Turnip, Collard, & Mustard Greens - Mixed (Vegetarian)
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Candied Yams
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Roasted Vegetables
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Rice
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Cabbage
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Tossed Salad
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Sweet Potato Cornbread
1/2 Pan (10 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (20 servings) $50.00
Corn Muffins
1/2 Pan (24 servings) $25.00| Full Pan (48 servings) $50.00
Desserts
Triple Chocolate Cake
$25.00
Butter Cake
$25.00
Caramel Cake
$25.00
German Chocolate Cake
$25.00
Red Velvet Cake
$25.00
Cupcakes
$25.00
Apple Pie
$25.00
Pig Lickin’ Cake
$25.00
Strawberry Banana Pudding Cake
$45.00
Sweet Potato Pie
$15.00
Peach Cobbler
$50.00
Banana Pudding
$50.00
Cookies / Brownies / Bars
$10.00
Fruit Pizza
$35.00
Buffet
20 Guest Minimum • *Whole Turkeys Not Included
1 Entree 2 Sides with Cornbread or Rolls
$20.00/per person
2 Entree 4 Sides with Cornbread or Rolls
$22.00/per person
Desserts
$4.00/per person